Cusumano

Welcome to Cusumano, a gem nestled in the heart of Old Forge, Pennsylvania. Located at 432 S Main St, this Italian restaurant invites you into a world where culinary passion meets heartfelt hospitality. As you step inside, you're not just entering a restaurant; you're becoming a part of a rich tradition that celebrates the essence of Italian cuisine.

Cusumano is renowned for its delectable array of dishes that cater to both classic and contemporary palates. The menu is thoughtfully curated, featuring everything from hearty appetizers like the alluring Clams Cusumano—steamed clams with sausage and basil pesto—to exquisite signature entrees such as My Grandmother's Chicken, which boasts succulent roasted chicken deglazed with vinegar, honey, and sherry wine. It's a dish that whispers tales of home-cooked memories with each bite.

  • Location: 432 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518
  • Contact: +1 570-457-4166
  • All Day Salads: Options include a Caesar Salad and a Bibb Salad with honey basil dressing.
  • Signature Entrees: Choices like Grilled Salmon with orange basil reduction.

One of the highlights of Cusumano is its warm and inviting atmosphere. Many guests have shared their delightful experiences, such as Matthew Lyons, who praised the restaurant's excellent service and the impressive charcuterie board—a perfect choice for larger gatherings. Then there's Tavin Brooks, who articulately captures the restaurant's spirit, noting the great selection of Italian dishes that cater to both date nights and family outings.

In addition, patrons rave about the exceptional cooking time for their famous pizzas, an art that requires patience yet rewards diners with remarkable taste. The crust, described as "textbook perfect" by James Williams, remains a talking point long after the meal concludes.

But what truly sets Cusumano apart is the dedication of its owner, Tj, who is deeply passionate about ensuring each guest has the best dining experience. His attention to quality and community shines through every dish served, making it a true culinary treasure.

Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual meal with family and friends, Cusumano promises a remarkable dining journey filled with flavor, warmth, and unforgettable memories. Visit them today and discover why so many have become regulars at this charming Italian establishment.

Menu

Location

Address: 432 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518, United States
Phone: +1 570-457-4166

🕓 Work Hours
MON Closed
TUE Closed
WED 5:00 AM - 9:00 PM
THU 5:00 AM - 9:00 PM
FRI 5:00 AM - 10:00 PM
SAT 5:00 AM - 10:00 PM
SUN 5:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Business info

  • Wheelchair-accessible Car Park
    Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible Entrance
    Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible Seating
    Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible Toilet
    Yes
  • Outdoor Seating
    Yes
  • Offers Delivery
    Yes
  • Offers Takeaway
    Yes
  • Serves Dine-in
    Yes
  • Fast Service
    Yes
  • Serves Great Cocktails
    Yes
  • Serves Great Dessert
    Yes
  • Great Wine List
    Yes
  • Popular For Lunch
    Yes
  • Popular For Dinner
    Yes
  • Good For Solo Dining
    Yes
  • Serves Alcohol
    Yes
  • Serves Beer
    Yes
  • Serves Cocktails
    Yes
  • Serves Coffee
    Yes
  • Serves Comfort Food
    Yes
  • Serves Food
    Yes
  • Serves Spirits
    Yes
  • Serves Wine
    Yes
  • Serves Lunch
    Yes
  • Serves Dinner
    Yes
  • Catering
    Yes
  • Serves Dessert
    Yes
  • Seating
    Yes
  • Bar On Site
    Yes
  • Toilet
    Yes
  • Casual
    Yes
  • Cosy
    Yes
  • Romantic
    Yes
  • Trendy
    Yes
  • Good For Groups
    Yes
  • Dinner Reservations Recommended
    Yes
  • Accepts Reservations
    Yes
  • Accepts Credit Cards
    Yes
  • Accepts Debit Cards
    Yes
  • Accepts NFC Mobile Payments
    Yes
  • Credit Cards
    Yes
  • High Chairs Available
    Yes
  • Free Of Charge Street Parking
    Yes
  • Free Parking Lot
    Yes
  • Plenty Of Parking
    Yes

Last Reviews

  • Author: Matthew Lyons

    06 June 2025

    We tried this restaurant recently and really liked it. Despite being incredibly busy when we stopped in, they found us a table and the service throughout was excellent and very friendly. The food was very good as well. We started with the charcuterie board, which was the biggest board I've ever seen, perfect for large groups, then we ordered the chicken, which was very good, and the pork chop that was excellent. We would definitely go back!

  • Author: Daniel Pompey

    11 May 2025

    Very nice. My sister and brother-in-laws favorite night out in Old Forge. Had a private family dinner for 12. Terrific service & atmosphere. Great menu & specials. Excellent presentation & quality. Highly recommended.

  • Author: Michael Kruchinsky

    05 May 2025

    We have become regulars at Cusumano and always enjoy our dinners. The service is great, the staff is friendly and the food is always delicious.

  • Author: Ryan Cywinski

    06 April 2025

    My wife and I went there for our anniversary. We are quickly created and see it in a friendly manner. Restaurant was extremely clean. Food was very good and the atmosphere was very relaxing. I have a stake in my wife had the chicken franchise. Both were extremely tasty and filling. Service - 10 Cleanliness - 10 Speed - 10 Quality - 10 Value - 10 Overall dining experience - 10